Evaluation Report
65 crickets used (not all questions answered by everyone)
18 qualitative responses online (via SurveyMonkey)
One interesting fact of the day was the relatively high proportion (37%) of University Library employees who had experience of being a student at Anglia Ruskin University .
The majority (54%) of respondents felt the best way to describe the day as a whole was enjoyable, followed by 29% who felt it was informative.
As you would hope, the vast majority of respondents considered the library to be very important to the University’s success.
Session feedback
Which session do you feel will be the most useful in your day to day work?
Angela Forster, Newcastle City Library – Transforming Customer Service
Of the respondents, 95% voted this talk good or excellent and 100% voted it excellent, good or okay. The qualitative results support this, commending Angela on her inspirational and well presented talk. The respondents felt that as Angela was from a public library this offered an interesting contrast and comparison to our own service, but that it still gave plenty of good practice ideas which we could apply.
Comments included:
Inspirational, good speaker, good comparison between academic and public library, best practice ideas.
Interesting and as/inspirational. Rather obvious as to why management wanted to include this example. Not sure the discussion session later was followed through on issues and themes raised.
Extremely good. She is a very accomplished presenter and has relevant things to say. It was interesting because her Library is not the same as ours, yet tackles many of the same issues, so it made us think. Could not really be bettered, with a speaker like this.
Question Time
Of the respondents, 87% thought Question Time was excellent, good or okay. Norman was highly commended for his role as chair, but problems with the microphones and the lack of occurring debate meant a lower rating by respondents. Although some respondents felt there were some beneficial insights gained, it seems the idea did not work in practice as we would have hoped. For the future: something active for after lunch might ensure the audience stays well awake.
Comments included:
Microphones, did the idea work in practice? Norman did a good job
This needed more controversial topics/ questions so a debate could be started between the participants and the audience.
Good. I thought Norman did a good job at introducing the session and trying to get interaction between the speakers. All the speakers gave interesting answers to the questions and some useful insights and overlaps in thinking. The MA student was specifically interesting and really good to see how education can really make a difference.
The theory of this was really good, but in practice it lacked a certain something. Microphones were clearly a problem, and for a institution of this standing, this was not acceptable. The panel were well experienced but found it difficult to engage with audience and each other. It was a great idea, and could work again given the right circumstances and support.
Feel that the panel was too biased towards the university - not enough views from our customers (e.g. students). Probably better to interview students about their views (on camera?) and discuss how to improve our services after viewing the film. Timing after lunch not good - difficult to stay engaged.
Group discussion activity on the Presentation Guidelines for the University Library Environment
90% thought the session was excellent, good or okay, more than half thought it was good or excellent. The group discussion activity was seen by some respondents to be a useful chance to offer their opinion, however there was some criticism that there was too much to cover in the allotted time and some concern that their responses might have little impact on the final document. Respondents also commented that Angela Forster’s talk should have more influence on the guidelines.
Comments included:
Seemed the wrong way round to me - if you want to change our culture, discuss the rationale before introducing a list of rules. Library buildings are only part of our offer, I thought Lesley Dobree's question about the offer for distance learners much more relevant!
Good idea to get us to say specifically what we would like to add/ subtract/ change instead of something vague. Perhaps the version of the guidelines was too long - a summarised version would have made it easier to focus.
Good way to network with staff you don't often see. Not sure whether the comments will be acted upon - sometimes think these documents are set in stone and used only to provide a group activity!
Did the human bingo and the hobbies and interests activities make networking easier?
The majority (83%) of respondents agreed that the human bingo and the hobbies and interests activities made networking and getting to know colleagues easier. Respondents found both events enjoyable but wished they had more time.
Comments included:
Bingo was a good ice-breaker to encourage networking. Hobbies was a good idea as it gave people a chance to show another side of themselves from outside the workplace.
Very good ice breaker and created a positive buzz.
Great fun though would have been better if had more time. As it was combined with coffee break it did depend on where you were in the queue.
Do you think the layout works better this year?
How was the food this year?
Of the respondents 92% considered the venue to be good or excellent. Of the 50 who attended last year, 86% thought the layout had been improved, the rest were unsure…
81% felt the food this year was either good or excellent, however there was criticism of the poor labelling, especially of the vegetarian food.
Comments included:
Great idea to have two food queues, split the wait nicely. Food was excellent
Venue excellent especially option to spill over into garden by river during lunch. Layout fine
The food was excellent and the venue was large enough to accomodate everyone who participated. It was quite simplistic in as much as we only needed to be in one of two rooms.
Overall excellent. Only criticism is that the food could have been better labelled. One table it wasn't labelled at all. I know this sounds trivial but as a vegetarian there is nothing worse than have to rely on others as unofficial tasters to tell you what's in a sandwich and no one wants to have to lift the corner of a sandwich, prod around and then either put it back or bin it!
And finally…
Almost 30% of respondents felt more confident and clear about how students view the university library and the service we provide and 65% reported they felt the same. Perhaps we could have focused more on student opinion as part of the events.
Evaluation exercise using Crickets
Using the crickets to give feedback went down well with 94% agreeing that they were fun to use.
Comments included:
Cricket feedback was excellent and should be used every year.
The evaluation session was very entertaining.
Hopefully plenty of people have been back to look at the Conference Blog to look at the photos, 80% agreed that they would…
Other comments
Other comments focused on timing, more specifically making sure session didn’t over run and interrupt breaks, as well as making sure the afternoon tea break is long enough. And there were ideas for future conferences: afternoon workshops, posters sessions and the experience of overseas/international students and emerging themes in the literature were amongst the suggestions.
Comments included:
Criticisms
Try to avoid too much sitting in one place, especially in afternoon. Please post presentation from guest speaker on conference blog so people who couldn't attend can catch up.
Ensure things & people run to time....... this really is important and needs special management.
Praise
Thank you for all your hard work in organising it.
Ideas for the future
One thing I preferred about last years conference was the afternoon workshops on various topics/interests. I would like there to have been something similar for this year because it was really good to learn a few different things and made the conference interesting, so ideally i would like to see this re-introduced for next year.
Whatever the theme, if you have an interesting keynote speaker from a library we can both compare and contrast with our own, it will help to animate the whole day. We were referring to Angela Forster during subsequent sessions which showed this.
Get Nicky to speak last in order to shake up pre-conceptions; Mix the sites up by arranging seating with reservation labels and names; why not use the topic of 'new roles in libraries' or trawl the literature for themes that are emerging.
Overseas students what are doing to help them [?]. Distance learners help for them [?].











